Is maintenance mandatory — even for vacant or rented flats?

Yes — completely and unconditionally. Maintenance charges are mandatory for every flat owner in India, regardless of whether the flat is occupied, vacant, locked, or rented out. This is one of the most commonly contested issues in housing societies, and the Supreme Court has settled it clearly.

The legal basis is the concept of collective ownership of common areas. As a flat owner, you have an undivided share in the lifts, corridors, stairwells, water tanks, generators, swimming pools, gardens, and all other common facilities. Your share of these costs does not disappear because you chose not to occupy the flat. The building still needs to be maintained, secured, and operated — and every owner must contribute proportionately.

Specific positions across recent cases:

How maintenance charges are calculated

This is the source of most society disputes. Three methods are used across India:

Method 1: Equal division (per unit / flat basis)

All flat owners pay the same amount regardless of flat size or type. A 1BHK owner pays the same as a 4BHK owner. This method is simple and administratively easy. Under Maharashtra law, this has historically been the legally mandated basis for cooperative housing societies under the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act. A Mumbai Co-operative Court restrained a society in January 2025 from shifting to per-square-foot basis without a proper legal basis — ordering reversion to per-unit billing until the dispute is resolved.

Method 2: Per-square-foot basis (proportional)

Larger flats pay more, in proportion to their carpet area or undivided share in the common area. This method is used by condominiums registered under state Apartment Ownership Acts (separate from cooperative society law). The Bombay High Court upheld this method in August 2025 in Sachin Malpani v. Nilam Patil for a condominium registered under the Maharashtra Apartment Ownership Act — holding that Section 10 of that Act requires charges to be proportionate to the undivided interest in the common area. A 4BHK flat owner tried to resist paying proportionately more — the court said they must pay based on their larger share of the common area.

Method 3: Hybrid

A base fixed charge for all units plus a variable per-square-foot component for some services. Common in gated communities where some costs (security, basic amenities) are equally shared and others (parking, extra water, premium amenities) are based on unit size or usage. This method must be clearly documented in the bylaws.

The governing document determines the method

Whether your society can use per-unit or per-square-foot charging depends on the governing document — the registered bylaws, deed of declaration, or sale agreement. The managing committee cannot unilaterally change the calculation method. Any change requires a resolution passed at the Annual General Meeting (AGM) or Special General Meeting by the required majority (usually 2/3 or 3/4 of members). A unilateral change in calculation method by the managing committee alone can be challenged before the Registrar or Cooperative Court.

What does maintenance cover — and what it should not

Maintenance charges typically cover a defined list of expenses. Knowing what is permitted helps you spot overcharging.

Component Permitted? Notes
Security staff salaries ✓ Yes Core common expense
Housekeeping and cleaning ✓ Yes Common areas only — not individual flats
Lift maintenance ✓ Yes AMC, electricity, repairs
Water charges ✓ Yes Bulk water supply to the building
Generator/DG set electricity ✓ Yes For common area power backup
Garden/landscaping maintenance ✓ Yes Common areas
Building insurance ✓ Yes Structure insurance for the complex
Sinking fund ✓ Yes (separate) Must be maintained in a separate account for major repairs
Repairs to individual flats ✗ No Interior repairs are individual owner's responsibility
Personal parking charges above standard Only if in bylaws Must be disclosed and approved
Profit or management fees to builder ✗ No Supreme Court ruled maintenance cannot be a profit-making activity
Penalty or interest on late payment Only if in bylaws Must be specified in bylaws; cannot be arbitrarily imposed

The sinking fund — what it is and how it is often misused

The sinking fund (or major repair/capital replacement fund) is a mandatory reserve collected separately from regular maintenance charges. Its purpose is to accumulate money for major future expenses — building repainting, lift replacement, water pump overhaul, structural repairs — that occur infrequently but cost large sums.

Legal requirements for the sinking fund

Common misuses of the sinking fund

Misuse of the sinking fund can be reported to the Registrar of Cooperative Societies. The managing committee can be held personally liable for any loss caused by misuse. Members can demand an audit by the Registrar under cooperative society law.

Society overcharging or misusing maintenance funds?

Free, confidential, in your language. Our AI will tell you whether your complaint is legally valid and exactly which authority to approach.
Ask Legal AI — free

GST on housing society maintenance charges

GST at 18% is applicable on maintenance charges collected by housing societies, cooperative housing societies, and apartment owners associations under the following conditions:

When GST applies

When GST does NOT apply

The threshold is per flat per month, not per building. If your flat's monthly maintenance is ₹12,000, GST of 18% (₹2,160) applies on the entire ₹12,000. If it is ₹7,000, GST does not apply.

Watch out for splitting charges to avoid GST

Some societies split the monthly bill into "maintenance" and "other charges" to bring each component under ₹7,500 and avoid GST. The GST department has clarified that all charges collected by the society for maintenance purposes must be aggregated to determine the ₹7,500 threshold — the total maintenance charge to the flat owner is what matters, not how it is split on the bill. If the total exceeds ₹7,500, GST applies.

Society's GST obligations

If GST applies, the society must:

A society that collects GST from residents but does not deposit it with the government, or that does not issue proper tax invoices, can be reported to the GST Department. Members can inspect the society's GST returns at the society office.

Who pays maintenance for a rented flat?

This is one of the most frequently confused issues between landlords and tenants in India. The answer has two distinct layers:

Layer 1: Society vs flat owner (landlord)

The housing society's relationship is with the flat owner (the member). The society can only recover maintenance charges from the registered member, not from a tenant. If maintenance is not paid, the society will send notices to and take action against the flat owner, not the tenant.

Layer 2: Landlord vs tenant (internal arrangement)

Between landlord and tenant, the rental agreement determines who pays. Three common arrangements:

Practical protections for tenants

Amenity denial — when societies discriminate

A growing problem in metro gated communities: societies that deny access to amenities (gym, pool, clubhouse, play area) to certain residents — smaller flat owners, tenants, bachelors, non-members. This is increasingly being challenged in courts.

The April 2026 Karnataka incident

A gated community in Karnataka made headlines when it denied 1BHK and 1RK residents access to the swimming pool and gym despite charging them full maintenance. The incident went viral. Legal experts confirmed that if residents are paying maintenance charges for common amenities, denying access to those amenities on the basis of flat size is discriminatory and legally indefensible. Residents were advised to: file a complaint with the Registrar of Cooperative Societies; issue legal notice to the RWA Chairman; and document the denial with video evidence for consumer court proceedings.

The legal position on amenity access

Builder and developer maintenance disputes

Before a Residents Welfare Association (RWA) or Apartment Owners Association (AOA) is formed, the builder typically manages maintenance. This is the source of significant disputes.

RERA rules on pre-possession maintenance

Transfer to AOA/RWA

Once the project is complete and the AOA/RWA is formed, the builder must transfer the maintenance corpus and accounts to the association. Delay in this transfer is a common complaint. If the builder delays or refuses to transfer, file a complaint before RERA. Most state RERA regulations have specific provisions requiring builders to hand over the maintenance fund within a specified time after formation of the residents' association.

Need help with a society dispute or RERA complaint?

Book a verified housing lawyer for ₹99. They'll assess your specific situation and tell you which forum to approach and how to build the strongest complaint.
Book a Lawyer — ₹99

How to resolve a maintenance dispute — your complete toolkit

Forum 1: Registrar of Cooperative Societies (primary forum)

For cooperative housing society disputes (which covers the majority of housing societies in India), the Registrar of Cooperative Societies is the primary administrative forum. The Registrar can:

Filing a complaint with the Registrar is free or involves minimal court fees. It is the fastest administrative route. In Maharashtra, complaints against cooperative housing societies go to the Deputy Registrar or the Sub-Divisional Officer (depending on the nature of the dispute).

Forum 2: Cooperative Court

For specific monetary disputes — recovery of excess maintenance paid, compensation for denied amenities, challenge to illegally imposed charges — the Cooperative Court has jurisdiction. Cooperative Courts function like civil courts but specifically for cooperative society disputes. Available in Maharashtra, Karnataka, Gujarat, and some other states.

Forum 3: Consumer Commission

For complaints involving deficiency of service — the society failing to maintain promised amenities, the builder not delivering promised facilities, poor quality services despite full payment — the District Consumer Commission is appropriate. Consumer cases must be filed within 2 years of the cause of action. You can claim: refund of excess charges, compensation for substandard service, interest on overpaid amounts, and cost of litigation.

Forum 4: RERA

For disputes involving the builder/developer — charging maintenance before possession, not disclosing maintenance charges in the sale agreement, not transferring the maintenance fund to the AOA, failure to provide promised amenities — file before your state RERA authority. RERA's jurisdiction ends once the project is fully handed over and the AOA is formed; thereafter, it is the cooperative courts that handle disputes.

Forum 5: Civil Court / High Court

For cases involving fundamental legal questions (challenging the legality of a bylaw amendment, challenging the formation of the AOA, constitutional questions about discrimination) — the Civil Court or High Court is the appropriate forum. Also applicable where no specific cooperative court/RERA forum exists for the nature of the dispute.

Society maintenance — questions people actually ask

Can the society put my name on a "defaulters list" for non-payment?

Yes — most cooperative society bylaws permit the managing committee to display a list of defaulting members at the notice board. This is a legitimate administrative measure to prompt payment, not defamation. However, if the society puts your name on a defaulters list incorrectly (you have paid, or the amount claimed is disputed and sub-judice), that could be defamation — send a legal notice to the Secretary demanding immediate removal.

Can the society refuse to give me an NOC for flat sale if I have maintenance arrears?

Yes. Most cooperative housing societies are entitled to withhold the No Objection Certificate (NOC) required for transferring the flat until all maintenance arrears (including penalty and interest as per bylaws) are cleared. The buyer cannot become a member of the society until the NOC is issued. This is a strong practical incentive for sellers to clear dues before selling. Any disputes about the arrears amount should be resolved before initiating the sale process.

How do I get the society's financial accounts?

As a member of a cooperative housing society, you have a statutory right to inspect the society's accounts and financial records. Under cooperative society law (state-specific, e.g., Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act), members can demand to see the annual accounts, audit report, bank statements, maintenance collection records, and sinking fund account. Submit a written request to the Secretary. If refused, file a complaint with the Registrar — this right cannot be denied to a member in good standing.

Can the society pass a resolution at AGM to suddenly double the maintenance?

The AGM has wide powers over maintenance — it can revise the maintenance amount, change the calculation method, and create new funds. However, the increase must be: (a) justified by actual cost increases (audited accounts); (b) passed by the required majority; and (c) notified to members in advance with proper AGM notice (typically 21 days). An arbitrary doubling without any cost justification can be challenged before the Registrar on grounds of unreasonableness or illegality. Courts have held that society charges must reflect actual expenses — they cannot be inflated arbitrarily.

What if the managing committee is corrupt and misusing maintenance funds?

File a complaint with the Registrar of Cooperative Societies immediately. The Registrar can order a special audit, freeze the society's accounts, and refer the matter for criminal investigation if fraud is suspected. Additionally, 1/5th of the members can call a Special General Meeting to remove the managing committee through a vote of no confidence. Keep all evidence — bank statements, receipts, accounts books — and if criminal conduct is suspected (embezzlement), file an FIR as well. The managing committee members can be personally liable for any loss caused by fraud or gross misuse.

Is parking charges part of maintenance?

Parking charges are a separate item from regular maintenance. Under many cooperative society bylaws, parking spaces are either allotted to members or managed as common areas. Any charge for parking must be specified in the bylaws and approved by the general body. Unilateral imposition of parking charges by the managing committee without bylaw authority can be challenged. For open parking spaces in common areas, the society cannot charge individual members beyond what the bylaws permit.